mmankt's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Project Retribution]

Pretty boring

I know you worked hard on this but this was just so unsophisticated, same old stick fight with lame chit-chat. Sorry to be harsh on you. Ugly background, ugly dust. The smooth motion is the only strong point here. You should work on something more graphically complicated. cheers

[Demo Reel 2009]

Outstanding.

A very good demo of your skills. Some of the scenes are really impressive. You have a great feeling of motion, expression and a good line. I like how you make the faces- no anime bullshit. The only thing missing for me is some gradients and details on the clothes and overall shading, however I totally understand how time consuming it is to add such stuff. You really have the goods to be a pro.

[RW:]

Great stick action.

But it's only a stick action sequence so as great as it is it only deserves a an honest 4 .
Animation quality and effects are very well done - but nothing too brilliant. The action was fast, the music great and blood fluid.
You are very good at this stuff but it's time to move on to something more unique.

[Madness Psychosis]

Regular madness but very well done.

Your animation turned out pretty well. One of the best trubutes i've seen in a while.
I like some of the new madness characters look and the whole angry idea. Unfortunately you totally blew the ending. As far as madness is awesome and you're good at it you should focus or something more unique. good luck.

[Portal Madness!]

great idea..

unused. you should make it longer , portal gun gives so many options that jumping of a one guy is not enough. hopefully youll make a full sequel sometime.

[L4D Short: The Witch]

what a sorry piece of shit!

not funny, ugly graphics style..if you show your love for this game in this way..well, you better don't.

[Santa's Last Stop]

totally awesome!

It was fun as hell, drawn in a very nice style. it wasnt immpressive but i liked it very much. the voice acting was great-specially santa. great work man, i really loled to this one keep up!

[Frost'D]

owned

hah, really awesome movie and idea. animation could use some more frames however it has a great atmosphere as it is. i always look forward to all of your submissions, great job man.

MindChamber responds:

yeah I started getting tired and ended up just inking the rough and not adding anymore animation haha. I wish my ideas came to me sooner.. thanks for the review!

[Fallen Angel Ep. 1 (Pt3)]

So many years of waitng...

and I'm totally disappointed. The teaser was outstanding for it's times. It promised that you can bring something great here..You inspired me years ago to try to make quality work.
/I'm writing this as a review of episode 1/
First two parts were pretty boring, part 3 finally showed something interesting.
The story is pretty basic, end of the world, a sexy(for 12-year olds) girl survives and tries to live. Maybe the next episodes will bring some unusual and interesting events. So far it's pretty lame.
The graphics- you've almost perfected the backgrounds and the vehicles, however they lack some detail on textures and color shades. On the other hand the characters look tragically most of the time. Poor animation, poor effects-worst explosions ever-except the nuclear blast-it turned out great. you should get a new and good animation artist.
The sound work was very well done, but the voice actors should try harder because they sound flat and unconvincing.
I totally respect your work but many of the users and other authors expected a lot from this series and unfortunately you didn't deliver the goods.
Still, I'm waiting for episode 2-if it will ever come out. Good luck.

[Madness-Solipsistic part1]

great.

I like the style and the new look you gave to the madness. It looks better then any madness tribute yet. good luck!