mmankt's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[L337 Kr3w: Reanimation]

It looks like crap..

HOWEVER it is totally awesome!
This flash has a lot to offer and it has got a great style. Moreover its ridiculous humor and situations made my today's tough morning.
Despite the poor gfx it is a very well crafted flash: voices, sounds and length of it are perfect. Every fight is special and every character diffrent.It feels like first Metal Gear Awesome- you watch a graphical piece of shit but you love it anyway.
Usually I gave such movies a 3 but you have a nice 4 from me and an encouragement to make more of these. Good luck.

[Tankmen Infinity]

Almost better than the original.

Really, really great job.
Whole feel of JohnnyUtah's Tankman was here. Great sound, story and animations. One of the most complete Picoday submission ever. It should win, period. Awesome work!

[Outlaw pt.1]

Looking good.

The movie as a whole is very interesting. The story looks quite good and the whole "competition" will keep things hot.
Drawings-especially faces,weapons and hands look very good , however you should put a lot more details into clothes. Also character animation is pretty poor. I think that you use way too much tweens without easing and horrible skewing.
On the other hand animations made by hand look pretty good. I liked the explosion.
Overall this flash is very promising,hope you won't ruin the plot like in Jazza's Paladin, and put some more work into it. Good luck and I'm waiting for part 2.

BiffTheTimid responds:

In the second one, Brooks gets a sword that turns his hair turquoise, and he has wings. Also the main villain is a necromancer that has turned the world into a living hell. They will eventually fight on-top of a huge tower. Oh, and he'll have a goatee too.

[The Smoking Kills Collab]

Worst collab Ive seen in a while.

Animations, drawings, sounds, backgrounds and kill ideas were all a TRAGEDY!. Im sorry but it's true. Are you blind?

[Our Aeipathy]

Awful!

People watching this must be blind and deaf.
This flash is a set of drawings(some are nicely done but others are just horrible (!!!). There is almost no animation: static figures are tweened through the scene. blah. Also this music is just horrible!!!
Pico sez: this makes poop look good. Try harder next time. ANIMATE!

skarl3tte responds:

Oh no, they are not blind and deaf, you probably just didn't look far enough back in the reviews.

But thanks for the critique. Again, this was something I did in a matter of hours for lack of something better to do =] Sorry, I probably should not have posted something like this on NG. I'm working on a serious flash at the moment, so that will definately be better. Thanks for not blamming, even though it's "horrible".

[Protectors of Tomorrow]

Funny.

But its not a movie, rather an animated comic. Adding lip sync to static characters, and a 2 -frame hit animation doesn't make a movie. Drawings are nice, sounds either. the plot is pretty funny, however it's nothing too original.Fully animate the characters next time. Doing it in flash would be much better.

[Disk extermination]

Its done pretty well but..

it lacks the tempo of a fight, everything is too slow. Also the sounds are not too good, however I really like your backgrounds and some of the animations, they are very fluid but as I said-too slow. Kepp up!

NOBU777 responds:

Since the speediness in action is important even though that is not right, I would like to take care from next time, although based also on the spec of PC to view.

[How 2 Succeed on NG]

Damn true man...

what can I say.. this is just NG life. Im sick of those anime and "awesomefuckingsomething" kind movies. Sometimes it just sucks when so many quality movies are hidden somewhere around the portal and a piece of shit is landing on front page..About your flash: nice drawing and lip lync of the narrator..(he could be less static) good voice recording and sounds. waiting for more!

BiffTheTimid responds:

Thanks for the constructive review. I dig the intruder series.

[Waterlollies]

Im speechless..

I shouldn't even dare to write to you..You are a flash GOD!
Just amazing. Ive been waiting for this Bitney story since last one..No one can match you Adam..Almost everything in this story is perfect!! Backgrounds, characters, all the effects..especially the water and water drops. I just cant imagine how the hell this movies score is not pure 5!! Any person who rates this movie below 5 must be jealous! This is state of the art..
I just can't imagine your next story from Brackenwood. Good luck! We love you.

[The Intruder!]

basic stick movie.

my INTRUDER is better:P