mmankt's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[:the Composer:]

Very nice, but overrated,

AND anybody noticed that he looks THE SAME as "palladin"?, and jazza - crying guys everywere? you must be very sensitive and cry everyday... overall a very good and ambitious flash with great drawing at some places and very basic at other. Keep up the good work.

[TRACER episode 1]

Great.

Really cool, rotoscope and motion capture as i call it. Everything is almost perfect. I don't like that arm tearing up scene-completely stupid and unreal. This will be great, but so far a solid 4 from me.

[PALADIN episode 5 part 2]

very uneven

what is quite static or just tweend, looks great. what is really animated sometimes looks horrible. u make too big deal out of this whole flash. the ending was sooo silly, and with American "happy end"..resurrected people..damn..it was completely stupid, good for small kids. but as a flash this is one of the best things here..

[Fallen Angel: Teaser]

great use of tricks.

really great movie with all the ways to avoid character animation. except falling animation and short 2 running loops there is no real character animation. tweened parts of body etc. but u know how to use montage and show this without disturbing. great car models, backgrounds(quite simple, but nice)and graphics. still one of the best submissions here on NG.

[PALADIN episode 5 part 1]

Impressive.

Really great work. You made a very big progress through this series from ugly part one to something as beautiful as this. Great face animation, especially of the evil wizard. He is a great character. The Paladin sometimes looks strange and acts like a fool but the whole flash is better than 96,9% of submissions on the web. Tremendous voice actors and nice music makes you forget about repetitive and, after all , quite stupid, basic hero-kind story. Only no "happy end" would make this better. Waiting for the 2nd part impatiently. Good luck.

[TRACER prequel]

Awesome.

The story is unclear at the moment but looks promising. I want to use the technique in my next flash movie. amazing work, I hope that you will complete this series guys. good luck!
PS that machine gun sound don't match to the rest. just a lil' tip ;)

[3D Pinball Animation]

u must have put..

a lot quite a lot effort to this, but this clip sucks. why?:
-the pinball table looks awful - 3dS max can do better rendering
-ugly textures
-no 'pinball' sounds only crappy music
last but not least(because it is MOST IMPORTANT)
THIS IS SLOOOOW..show me a normal pinball table with the ball and table stuff moving >that< slow and i will say "sorry" to you

StupidHumorKing responds:

You don't have to say sorry to me. If you don't like it, you don't like it, fair enough. Considering that this was my first ever 3D animation, I thought I did quite good but obviously I'm not that experienced yet. I'll try 3D animating again later in the future.

[Dark|Realms]

Supposed to be beter..

At first look this movie looked interesting. It has got very nice drawings in the first scene, but then they start fighting..omg.. awful. you are good at drawing static scenes, not animating..better luck in next part, however i see no future in this mini series(?).

Vermillion2 responds:

believe the only way to get better at something is by practice and hard work, im pleased with my flash and i know there's room for improvement,but u can't make everyone happy heh

[School Madness 2]

better then newest krinkel's movie.

Awesome "math fx", however it is a pity that u have used zombies again. make more uniforms and different clothes and masks, cuz those madness guys look crappy nowadays.
PS:POLSKA RZADZI !

[Oxygen]

whats the big deal?

Main charges:
This movie is really boring.
Drawings are shitty as hell.
Almost no real animation.
As far as I am concerned this movie is completely not worth the front page.

notorious responds:

thanks for reviewing, but your review isn't really helpful.

P.S. Most daily features get front page, probably because they're good ;) Not saying that your opinion is wrong by any means, I guess just more people liked it than didn't.